Joe and Mia have been married about 3 years. Joe has a sister that he is really trying to build their relationship again. Joe was very irresponsible growing up. He tries to show his family all time he isn't that person anymore.
THE SITUATION:
Joe's sister has been out of town for Easter break. It's a trip her family takes every year. Joe's sister has a daughter that is 5 and she is on the trip. Joe's sister's daughter has a hamster that she loves dearly. Joe begged his sister to let him watch the hamster while they were gone. He promised he would feed and play with it everyday. She didn't want to do it but finally agreed.
Weds when Joe got home from work, he checked on the hamster and it wasn't moving. Joe rushed it to the Vet (who happens to be a really good friend) and the Vet said that unfortunately the hamster wasn't going to make it. It had something that is rare but happens in hamsters sometime. Joe was blown away and had the Vet do what needed to be done so the hamster wouldn't suffer.
Before he left, the Vet told Joe that he had a hamster that family told him to find a good home. It looks exactly like the hamster that passed. Joe wants to take that hamster and replace it with the other one and tell no one. Once his sister finds out that the hamster died on Joe's watch, it will take their relationship back years. She wouldn't believe it was an accident and not speak to Joe.
Joe wants to put the hamster in the cage like nothing ever happened. Mia thinks he should tell his sister. Joe knows his family wouldn't believe the hamster died of natural causes. Even if the Vet told them, they know it's Joe's friend and may be lying. Joe has seen and played with both hamsters and there is no difference. They both just sit there and do nothing.
WHO DO YOU SIDE WITH ON SIDE TAKERS
Side with Joe and he will replace the hamster and no one will know
Side with Mia and he will tell his sister and risk their relationship